Taking your workplace pension? The questions worth asking
‘Stop the Pension Power Grab’ is quite a headline to come across over your Sunday coffee. It’s the name of a campaign by The Sunday Times about a government proposal to give people a ready-made way to turn their workplace pension pot into a regular income.
Imagine you’ve finally got round to calling your pension provider. You’ve spent years paying into the pot, you’ve got a date in mind for finishing work, and you’d like to know what you can take each month. The provider comes back with a figure and an option that could pay you for the rest of your life. After an afternoon spent looking for old pension statements, there’s quite a lot to like about someone giving you a straight answer.
But there are a few questions I’d want to ask before saying yes.
Would you have to take the option you’re offered?
You’d have a choice. Under the government’s proposals, the company or scheme that runs your workplace pension would offer eligible savers a ready-made income option when they ask to take money from their pot. The aim is to make that decision easier and help people avoid running out of money later in retirement.
The government calls this ‘guided retirement’. You’ll also see the word ‘default’, which makes it sound as though something might happen if you leave the paperwork on the kitchen table. In reality, nothing happens unless you act - your pot simply stays invested until you contact your provider and actively agree to start taking an income.
The question is how many of us would look beyond this default option. Take annuities, which turn some or all of your pension pot into a guaranteed income. It’s easy to see why you’d buy one from the company that already holds your pension - they’ve got your details, they’ve given you a figure and you can tick another job off the list. But another company might pay you more each year for the same pot. It’s worth comparing what you’d get each month and whether you could take a bit more in a year when you need it.
Of course the ready-made option might suit you, but it’s worth taking a moment to consider the options first.
Could your income go down?
That depends on what your provider’s ready-made option looks like. Each scheme would design its own, and the proposals allow for a few different approaches.
Some might use an annuity, which pays a guaranteed income for life. The amount won’t drop, but if it’s a fixed amount it will buy a little less each year as prices rise. You can get one that goes up with inflation, but it will usually start lower.
Others might put your pot into a collective pension., where your money is pooled with other people’s in one big fund. It aims to pay you an income that keeps up with inflation, but that’s a target rather than a promise. If the investments or the scheme’s finances go through a bad patch, your income could be cut.
So it’s worth asking your provider which parts of your income are guaranteed, which could change and, if they could, by how much.
What if you want to spend more in the first few years?
Former pensions minister Sir Steve Webb has questioned the emphasis the proposals put on an income for life. Think about what you’ve got planned for the first few years after you finish work and you can see his point.
Say your State Pension and another pension already cover the bills. You might want to take a bit more from this pot in the year you finally make that trip to see family in Australia. Once you’re back, you might need considerably less. With Guided Retirement, you might not be able to do this.
Stepping outside the default to use drawdown is one way to give yourself that flexibility though. You decide how much to take and when, and the rest stays invested. The trade-off is that the value of your pot can fall, and it could run out if you take too much too soon. Alternatively you could also use part of the pot to buy an annuity to cover some of the regular bills and leave the rest invested for the years when you’d like to spend a bit more.
What’s worth checking before you decide?
Start with what your pension needs to pay for. How much do you need for the bills, what else have you got coming in, and are there any years when you know you’ll want more? Once you’ve got those answers, it’s easier to compare the income on offer, see how much it could change and work out whether you’d be able to take extra money when you need it.
The consultation is open until 22 December 2026, so the details could still change. If you’re coming up to retirement and would like to talk through your options, just give us a call.
The information in this blog was correct as of 13 November 2026. A pension is a long-term investment not normally accessible until age 55 (57 from April 2028 unless the plan has a protected pension age).